Book Reviews | Current Edition | Literary Arts

Stripping the World of Beautiful Danger: Rob Carney’s The Book of Sharks

The Book of Sharks sounds like one of those fabulous fictional works that exist only in an author’s imagination, but in fact, Rob Carney has written an ambitious book of shark poetry that lives up to its mythological title.

His piercing shark poems have been swimming into ecological poetry journals a few at a time for a number of years: in 2013, “Seven Pages from the Book of Sharks” won the annual poetry prize from; in 2014, “Seven Circles in the Book of Sharks,” won the Robinson Jeffers/Tor House Foundation Poetry Prize; and in 2016, another frenzy of shark poems appeared in Uncivilised [sic] Poetics, volume 10.

The last is part of the “Dark Mountain Project,” out of the United Kingdom, which has been publishing an especially intriguing series of literary anthologies based on a premise that the current social, economic, and ecological unravelling is a consequence of false stories we tell ourselves about “progress.” In the formulation of the Dark Mountain Manifesto, storytelling is not just an amusement but a source of potent metaphors, the magical incantations that create reality. The editors of Uncivilised Poetics insist that poetry is a necessary response to the crumbling narratives of the modern world, a disheveled and unsettling alternate reality that “refuses the logical, reductionist, materialist aspects of industrial culture.”

Carney’s Book of Sharks exemplifies uncivilised poetics. His sharks are fierce Jungian archetypes, toothy shadows cruising through a turbulent collective unconscious. The poems form around invented myths and folktales that spring from an imaginary, deeply grounded culture, one that could conceivably be our own if it were radically transformed by the re-enchantment of the world.

The Book of Sharks is essentially one long poem  — seven sets of seven poems collected into cycles according to the magical calculus of folktales. Each poem is punctuated either with a tiny illustration of a shark tooth or a little celestial orb that looks like the planet Jupiter (Jupiter, Florida is a famous destination for “shark diving,” where people lowered in metal cages swim among sharks). The mythmaking works the image of sharks as classic sea-monsters, coldblooded, ancient creatures that evolved more than 416 million years ago during the Devonian “Age of Fishes.” Sharks are the jump-scare in horror movies. Their essence is their bite, which is their only tangible feature. They constantly grow new teeth and shed old ones. In the fossil record, shark teeth are all that remain since shark’s bodies are built on a structure of cartilage. Carney interprets this strange combination of eternity and transience as a myth:

In a story seldom remembered, sharks were ghosts

guarding the afterlife

Since their rendered bodies had no skeletons, 

just teeth.


These ghost-sharks pass judgement on the souls of the dead.  The worst sin, according to sharks, is the extermination of large predators which is to say, stripping the world of beautiful danger,


If they killed a bear, or left a wolf’s mate howling—

and the water is cold as a shark’s eyes.

And then they see the fins. 


Throughout the poem the sharks are teachers, sometimes in parables, and sometimes explicitly. As Prometheus gave fire to humanity, sharks give sharp, cutting things — bear traps, scythes, sandpaper and nails.


Some say sharks are the ocean’s blueprint for tools

a set of designs for us to imitate.


In earlier versions, Carney called these poems “circles” and they do circle, retelling a story with a new twist, or coming back to a repeated phrase, only to take off in some new direction.  One recurring character is a boy who tells his own life through stories about sharks:


The best explanation I know was offered by a boy.

His father was dead, and his mother couldn’t hear.

He said, “Sharks are the ocean’s way of talking.

Like talking with your hands.”


In another circle, Carney imagines placing sharks into constellations in order to elevate them to a state of divinity.


We could draw new lines across the night

teach a son or a daughter, “those three there together,
that’s the fin.


The Book of Sharks is so whimsical that when the punches hit there is an extra force of surprise. Carney raises psychological monsters and then re-tells their story to make them part of a human story. In his telling, the essence of the crisis, the unravelling, is that we are so terrified of our metaphorical sharks we think we can’t live with them. But Carney knows that we can’t live without them, either. He wonders,


In the end, standing at the gates of heaven,

What if we are asked one question: ”How are my sharks?”



The Book of Sharks
Rob Carney
Black Lawrence Press

Wasatch Wordsmiths present Sugar Slam, featuring Rob Carney, Thursday, Oct. 11, 8 pm at Watchtower Cafe, 1588 S. State, Salt Lake City.

3 replies »

  1. I hope this will be seen as my leaning in, rather than criticizing Ms Brunvand’s perceptive review. Britain and the US are two peoples divided by a common language, and some of our most implacable disagreements are typographical. S vs Z is one constant difference. “Uncivilised” is correct in a book published in England. A Brit who writes “Uncivilized” there can expect to be corrected (“sic”). I dream of the day my countrymen will consider it unremarkable when coming across the S in a British text. Perhaps the problem stems from our two nations not respecting each other’s copyrights. I can wish, but every day this country seems to respect other nations less.
    And of course the rest of the world has taken to laughing at US.

  2. This is one of Brunvand’s most trenchant reviews. Carney is a master of the the mythological wild. But you have to hear him recite, by memory, his work to truly experience it’s verve and resonance. Sorry to have missed his reading tonight.

  3. Geoff, I fear the [sic] was for the copy editor. Who should have removed it. And considered doing so, but failed to. Sorry, Amy Brunvand. Now it has to remain. Such a pithy review! I really was ready to run out and buy the book until: “and the water is cold as a shark’s eyes . . . and then they see the fins.” At which point I feared it was the stuff nightmares are made on. Mine, anyway. I may change my mind, but I did shiver. A fine piece of writing, on both your parts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.